UK’s electoral reform, explained by progressive leaders

While not as entertaining as when explained to cats, the Guardian nonetheless has perhaps the most “authoritative” defense of the alternative vote system. It is signed by Labour shadow business secretary John Denham, Lib Dem energy and climate change secretary Chris Huhne, leader of the Green Party Caroline Lucas.

I have long thought the British system – like the American – is thoroughly dysfunctional and undemocratic, robbing much of the electorate of their voice and depriving the government of much-needed legitimacy.

A summary of the article’s arguments, which I think on the whole are rather persuasive:

  • “You cannot build a fair society on an unfair politics. Britain consistently votes as a center-left country and yet the Conservatives have dominated our politics for two-thirds of the time since 1900. Only on two occasions in that long century – 1900 and 1931 – have the Tories won a majority of votes.
  • Margaret Thatcher’s “radical” reformist government twice had over 54% of people vote against her but she kept massive majorities. The electoral system, incidentally, had no incentive for her not to completely wreck Scotland and the north.
  • The “wasted vote” produces apathy. There is no point being a Conservative in Scotland or the north and no point being a progressive in much of the south. (The same problem is compounded in the United States by state-wide FPTP elections. There is no point voting outside a swing state (and, for that matter, no point being black in a Southern state).
  • This artificial polarization is “a recipe not for a parliament that holds up a mirror the nation, so that we can debate and resolve our differences, but one that deepens divisions and resentments.”
  • “Back in 1950, […] 85% of MPs won more than half of the vote in their constituency. Today, two thirds of MPs have more people voting against them than for them.
  • Foreigners: Few new democracies today adopt the British system, Australia adopted AV 80 years ago and New Zealand has adopted the German system. What a lonely “Mother of Parliaments”!
  • The Tories oppose AV as the current system gives them overwhelming parliamentary majorities with minority public support.
  • The racist British National Party opposes AV as they would be unable to get any majorities under this system. (An interesting, although possibly problematic, feature of AV is indeed being able to “censure” a candidate by all “mainstream” voters ranking him last.)
This entry was posted in lighter side, United Kingdom and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to UK’s electoral reform, explained by progressive leaders

  1. Pingback: Verfassungsblog › Ein moderne(re)s Wahlrecht für die Briten

  2. Pingback: UK’s electoral reform, explained by progressive leaders (via Letters from Europe) « Spineless Liberal

  3. Ross Nelhams says:

    Hey bud, nice blog!

    I particularly enjoyed reading a sensible account of why the electoral system in blighty needed reforming, I guess it’s partly due to the enforced-unbiased approach of the BBC but judging from the media coverage here you’d have thought people were being asked to understand Schroedinger’s Cat (and/or Mulholland Drive). I have been back here less than a year and am already almost going insane about how many times I have been told about justice and fairness by our new Prime Minister, Eton-educated and with FOURTEEN Old Etonians on his front bench, and a big appetite for cuts (and in my current job working in local schools I can tell you they’re biting!). Have you heard that the Scots are going to have a referendum on independence sometime in the next few years, as the SNP have won a majority up there? If the Scots are leaving, so am I!!!
    Keep up the good work, shall try to look in again soon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s